WE HAVE MOVED!! 11909 Lakeside Drive, Fishers, IN 46038, United States | 600 E Carmel Dr, Carmel, IN 46032, USA

IFS: Understanding the Critical Part

 by Allyson Utz

In our last post, we discussed how all of our parts that live in our mind and body have a positive intention. We may have some similar parts, like critical parts or happy parts, but we are also likely to have different parts, with how these parts show up in our minds, bodies, and lives being unique to each of us individually. In addition to these parts, we each have a Self, which exudes qualities like compassion, confidence, and curiosity. With these qualities, our Self helps us to recognize and interact with parts to find out about their roles, as well as the weight and pain they carry, which are commonly referred to as burdens. When we have Self-energy present, meaning we feel compassion and curiosity toward a part, we can begin to work with that specific part.

How are all parts "good"?

For some parts, it is easy to see how they are helping us. For instance, a studious part might help us do well in school and at work, and a silly part might help us make friends and be well-liked. Meanwhile, other parts get a bad reputation. It is harder for us to understand how procrastinating parts, anxiety parts, sad parts, or self-critical parts are trying to help us, and in general people speak pretty negatively about these parts. We can even see this play out in the movies Inside Out and Inside Out 2.

In the first movie, Joy is well-liked by Riley’s other parts, and they trust her to make Riley’s life better. Joy takes on this responsibility and works so hard to keep Sadness out of Riley’s life by making her stand far away from the control panel and giving her busy work.

Sadness becomes exiled. A similar theme arises in the sequel when Anxiety begins to take over with other new emotions, resulting in Joy, Anger, Sadness, Disgust, and Fear being exiled. 

In both instances, the protectors, Joy and Anxiety, have pure intentions. They think they are helping Riley be happy at all costs, or in Anxiety’s case be perfect at all costs. This mission is so important to them that they become rigid and inflexible about how to best achieve Riley’s well-being. It is almost as though Joy and Anxiety became so blended with Riley, that Riley started to be constantly speaking from their perspectives rather than from her Self.

This is later revealed when it becomes obvious that Joy thought that Riley had to always be happy for her parents and for herself. We also see instances of other parts blending with Riley, like Anger, when Riley lashes out at her parents after having a bad day at school. Another more extreme instance of a part blending with Riley is when Anxiety takes over and Riley experiences a panic attack.

The parts are here to help even if they seem critical and unhelpful.

When a part blends with the Self, a person is no longer speaking from Self, and instead, they are speaking from a specific part. Much like Joy and Anxiety, who had an “at all costs” mentality in regard to keeping Riley happy or perfect, many parts share this mindset, which contributes to them becoming too strict in their ways. The “at all costs” perspective can be understood through the lens of a self-critical part. Oftentimes, these critical parts emerge with the intention of helping us be “perfect” so we do not get rejected.

The self-critical part is commonly known as a protector because it tries to handle and cope with the pain from another part, an exile, that believes and carries the pain associated with the thought of not being good enough.

The self-critical part believes it is helping by making us “perfect,” and it will go as far as being our biggest critic. It might have started as a way to prevent us from receiving criticism from others, but this part eventually becomes extreme, and it criticizes us even when other people are not. 

A famous quote from Anne Frank is relevant to this discussion: “I’m my best and harshest critic. I know what’s good and what isn’t.” As Anne Frank expressed, a critical part can be helpful to a certain extent, but sometimes the self-critical part goes too far, and what it deems as “good” or “bad” is true in its reality, but may not be the case in the actual situation. In many cases, the self-critic’s role used to be necessary to protect a young exiled part, but now, the Self can help both parts by first speaking with the protector part. Many times, these protector and exiled parts think that we are younger than we are, as if stuck in the past. 

Imagine a young child who is excluded and bullied because she wears costumes to school. The self-critical part may emerge within this child and sound similar to her taunting peers, and this part starts to say things like “don’t wear that” and “they will laugh at you.” Another part of her starts to believe the critical part is right and changes herself to fit in, but the self-critic does not stop. As the child gets older, even throughout adulthood, she always tries to look “perfect,” keeping up with the latest fashion trends because this protector still thinks she is that vulnerable, bullied, little girl. Her critical part thinks it must keep criticising her to protect her from future harm. This part does not realize that it does not have to keep doing this job. 

How can Self help?

This is where the Self comes in. The Self can learn about this protector from a compassionate and curious stance to understand why it feels it must criticize the girl and how it thinks it is helping the girl. It is important to remember that if Self-energy is not present, we cannot properly explore our parts. If we feel hatred toward our self-critic part, this is actually another part talking, not our Self. We first need to address this part and see who it is, what its goals are, and how it is trying to help us. Then, we can ask it to step aside momentarily so we can reevaluate and see if our Self is present enough to work with the self-critic. The goal is not to force the self-critic or any part out of its role, but to allow these parts to see that they can rest and do different jobs. Eventually, with the self-critic’s permission, the exiled part, that believed the young girl was not good enough as she was, can be visited to discover what burdens this part carries. All in all, using parts via IFS helps us understand our many parts, support them, and heal altogether.

Some Questions to Consider

  1. Do you have a self-critic part?
  2. Have you misunderstood this part and viewed it as your enemy?
  3. How do you feel about approaching your self-critic part with curiosity and working to understand this part to help it heal?

 

If you’d like a therapist who can help support you in learning about your parts, please check out our team page. 

—>>> TEAM PAGE

Get Started With Therapy

Are you looking for therapy?

New and returning clients can book appointments or free consultations directly online. Prefer to send us a message?