WE HAVE MOVED!! 11909 Lakeside Drive, Fishers, IN 46038, United States | 600 E Carmel Dr, Carmel, IN 46032, USA

How Are People-Pleasing and Anxiety Related?

People-pleasing and its relation to anxiety are often misunderstood. It helps to have a concrete example.

Several years ago, there was a YouTube episode of a dog trainer working with a middle-aged mother and an adult daughter. This pair had an out-of-control labradoodle and needed help learning to manage him.

The trainer attempted to get this mother-daughter duo to walk their dog every morning to help train it. He wanted them to spend that time bonding with him and helping him release some extra energy.

The mother immediately said, “I’m not walking that dog! She can do it.” She motioned toward her daughter. The mother didn’t smile much; her arms were crossed, her feet firmly planted on the pavement. Frankly, she was a little scary.

The daughter had the opposite personality. She was continually smiling, overwhelmingly cooperative, engaging and pleasant. The daughter was more than willing to walk the dog every day and do anything the trainer asked. She didn’t seem to notice her mother’s mindset and if she needed to walk the dog every day, she would.

But then, something surprising happened.

The trainer looked at the camera behind the scenes and said, “Absolutely not. I am not going to allow this mother to push the responsibility off onto the daughter. They are both going to walk this dog. The problem here is Miss Beverly” (or whatever her name was—the mother). He went on to explain that the daughter had a real problem on her hands, and it was her mother not the dog.

I like this example when we attempt to understand people-pleasing, because it brings compassion and understanding of the big picture.

You didn’t become a people-pleaser for no reason. It was probably your only option.

People-pleasing is a survival skill that helps someone deal with a situation over which they legitimately don’t have control. The mother and daughter both owned the dog and were responsible for walking it, but one of them refused to do her part. That is an anxiety-provoking thing.

Anxiety and people-pleasing are related because people-pleasing is an attempt to manage the anxiety-provoking situation.

In DBT, fear and anxiety are the same thing and mean, “there’s a threat to my safety, my integrity, or that of a loved one”. What else could create a sense of a threat than when someone around you won’t do their fair share of the work? Why aren’t they concerned that you are having to do it all?

The problem is, long after the dynamic is over, a person who has had to cope this way is still being pleasant and agreeable to their detriment. It’s become a pattern and they aren’t aware of it.

People-pleasers end up overworked and tired, resentful, ill from lack of self-care, surrounded by toxic relationships, or they just don’t enjoy life anymore. It’s a very sad thing. 

The dog trainer’s response, “I am not allowing her to push the responsibility off on the daughter” was the antidote to the people-pleasing. It was thrilling, but let’s face it, the dog trainer didn’t have to live with Miss Beverly once the show was over and we have no idea what played out.

What can you do if you have (or had) a Miss Beverly in your life?

What can you do now if you realize you have anxiety that spins into a people-pleasing pattern?

  1. Learn to tolerate distress and sit with your feelings rather than immediately jump up, say yes, and take on the work yourself.
  2. For one week, say no to some small things. Track them in your phone.
  3. The next week, graduate up to some bigger things. Exercise the part of you that isn’t used to saying “NO”.
  4. Notice your anxiety and question it. Are things genuinely out of control? Do you need to help another person calm down (or should they be doing that?)
  5. Read some books on assertiveness. What does it look like? If you have 1000 ways to say no, it might make it easier for you.
  6. Practice saying no with a friend, therapist or a family member. Sometimes, you may just need to see that you can, in fact, do it without an avalanche coming down upon you.

At Free Clear Mind, we provide a safe environment for you to identify and work through the things that are causing you the most anxiety. Our therapists are sensitive counselors who understand sensitive people. With over 25 years of experience, we warmly invite you into a comfortable space where you can work on whatever people-pleasing patterns may be affecting your life.

We empower you to overcome anxiety, embrace confidence and enjoy life.

A free clear mind is the first step.

Get Started With Therapy

Are you looking for therapy?

New and returning clients can book appointments or free consultations directly online. Prefer to send us a message?